On this page
Key takeaways
- Every UK employer runs payroll in one of three ways.
- A dedicated payroll administrator brings salary, employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000, an employer pension contribution, holiday and sickness cover, training and the software they work in.
- Cloud payroll software is cheap to buy, often a modest monthly fee that rises with the number of employees.
- Outsourced payroll with us costs £5 per payslip per month, with no set-up fee and nothing extra for P45s, P60s, RTI submissions, auto-enrolment calculations or statutory pay calculations.
- For a business with 10 employees, outsourcing costs £50 a month, or £600 a year.
Questions about this? WhatsApp a payroll accountant or call 0800 644 1258.
The three options at a glance
Every UK employer runs payroll in one of three ways. You can employ someone to do it in-house, you can use payroll software and do it yourself, or you can outsource to an accountant or payroll bureau. Each shifts the balance between cost, control and risk, and none is right for every business. The right choice depends on your headcount, how complicated your pay is, and how much time and expertise you have.
The mistake most employers make is comparing the visible price only. Software looks cheap because the subscription is small. Outsourcing looks expensive because the invoice is a line item. In-house payroll looks free because the person is already on the payroll. In each case the real cost is hidden in time, training, errors and risk.
What in-house payroll really costs
A dedicated payroll administrator brings salary, employer National Insurance at 15% above £5,000, an employer pension contribution, holiday and sickness cover, training and the software they work in. Even a part-time role usually costs several thousand pounds a year, and a business with fewer than fifty employees rarely has enough work to justify more than part of a role.
The deeper problem is resilience. If the one person who knows the payroll is ill or leaves, you have a deadline and nobody who can meet it. In-house payroll also means someone must keep up with the annual changes to tax, National Insurance, pension and minimum wage rules, and attend training to do so. For larger employers with complex shift patterns, multiple sites and enough volume, an in-house team is sensible. For most small and medium businesses it is the most expensive route per payslip.
What do-it-yourself software really costs
Cloud payroll software is cheap to buy, often a modest monthly fee that rises with the number of employees. For a very small, simple payroll it can be a good choice, especially if you enjoy the detail and have time. But you are the payroll department. You enter the data, check the calculations, submit to HMRC, manage the pension, issue payslips, deal with starters and leavers and file the year-end forms.
The legal responsibility stays entirely with you. If you enter a wrong tax code, miss an auto-enrolment assessment or file late, the penalty is yours, and software does not take on any of that risk. For a business owner whose time is worth £40 or more an hour, four hours a month of payroll is a real cost of nearly £2,000 a year before any mistakes are counted.
What outsourcing costs, and what you get
Outsourced payroll with us costs £5 per payslip per month, with no set-up fee and nothing extra for P45s, P60s, RTI submissions, auto-enrolment calculations or statutory pay calculations. You send the pay changes, we prepare and check the run, you approve it, and we issue payslips and file with HMRC. A named contact is there when you have a question, and qualified accountants stand behind the work.
The cost is predictable, it moves with your team, and it requires none of your time beyond approving the run. Crucially, it transfers the compliance risk to a regulated firm that runs payroll for many clients and keeps up with every rule change as a matter of course.
Worked examples: 10 and 30 employees
For a business with 10 employees, outsourcing costs £50 a month, or £600 a year. DIY software might cost £300 to £500 a year in subscriptions, plus around four hours a month of owner or manager time. At £40 an hour that is about £1,920 a year, so the true cost is over £2,200 before any pension add-on or mistake. A part-time in-house administrator at even 10 hours a week would cost far more than either.
For 30 employees, outsourcing costs £150 a month, or £1,800 a year. Software time grows with headcount, and by this size the payroll typically takes a day or more each month. The business is now exposed to more starters, leavers, pension assessments and holiday calculations. The cost comparison still strongly favours outsourcing until the business is large enough to justify a full-time specialist.
Risk, control and data security
Cost is only one dimension. Control matters to many owners, and the fear of handing over sensitive pay data is understandable. A good outsourced model keeps you in control, because you approve every run before anything is paid or filed. Payroll data is personal data, so the provider acts as your processor under UK GDPR, with written terms covering security, confidentiality and what happens when you leave.
Regulation is a useful signal. An ICAEW regulated firm works to professional standards, carries insurance, and is accountable to a professional body. That is quite different from a one-person freelance bookkeeper or a software company that disclaims responsibility for the output.
When in-house or software is the better choice
Outsourcing is not always the answer. In-house payroll can make sense when you have several hundred employees, complex shift and overtime patterns, a need for real-time control, or integrated HR and time systems that feed payroll directly. Software alone suits a tiny business with one or two straightforward employees and an owner who wants to learn it.
Between those extremes, which covers most small and medium employers, outsourcing is usually the cheapest and safest option. If you are unsure, start by listing the hours your team spend on payroll each month and the mistakes you have made in the last year. The numbers usually make the decision obvious.
How to switch without disruption
If you decide to move, the process is straightforward. You give the new provider your PAYE and Accounts Office references, year-to-date figures, employee details, tax codes and pension scheme information, and authorise them as your agent with HMRC. A good provider handles the migration, checks the opening balances against HMRC records and runs the first pay period alongside you.
You can switch at any point in the tax year, you do not need to wait for April, and the right moment is usually the start of a pay period. Our guide to switching payroll provider walks through the steps and the documents you will need.
Monthly payroll
Your price
How many employees?
10 × £5 per month
£50
- Set-up fee
- £0
- Contract
- None
Includes PAYE, RTI, pensions, P60s and P45s. Prices exclude VAT where applicable.
Questions answered
Is outsourcing payroll safe for my data?+
A regulated firm handles payroll data under UK GDPR with documented security, access controls and confidentiality obligations. You should have a written agreement with the provider.
Can I go back in-house later?+
Yes. We hand over year-to-date records and reports so you can move at any time.
How many employees do I need before in-house makes sense?+
There is no fixed number, but most employers need several hundred staff, or unusually complex pay, before a dedicated in-house specialist is cost-effective.
Will I lose control of payroll if I outsource?+
No. You approve every pay run before payslips are issued and HMRC is notified.
What if my provider makes a mistake?+
Ask about the provider's insurance and how errors are corrected before you sign. With a professional firm, mistakes are corrected quickly and any penalty from our error is our responsibility.
How much does outsourced payroll cost?+
Our service is £5 per payslip per month with no set-up fee, so ten employees cost £50 a month.
Written and reviewed by the Accotax payroll team
Accotax is an ICAEW regulated accountancy firm in Morden, London, with ACCA and AAT qualified staff, rated 4.9 on Google from 300+ reviews. About us · Verify on the ICAEW directory
Sources and further reading
General information for UK employers, not personal advice. Rates and rules change, so check GOV.UK or ask us before you act. Canonical page: https://payrollservices.accountants/guides/payroll-in-house-vs-outsourced