Payroll software, bureau, in-house or us?
An honest side-by-side so you can choose what fits your business.
| DIY software | In-house hire | Traditional bureau | Payroll Services | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | Software fee plus your time | Salary, NI, pension, software | Set-up fee plus per run fees and add-ons | £5 per payslip per month |
| Who is accountable | You | Your employee, ultimately you | Bureau, within contract limits | Qualified accountants, with your approval |
| Pension auto-enrolment | You manage | Employee manages | Often an add-on | Included |
| P60s, P45s, RTI | You file | Employee files | Sometimes extra | Included |
| Cover for absence | None | Needs backup | Yes | Yes |
| Accounts and tax support | Separate firm | Separate firm | Rarely | Same firm available (Accotax) |
Read more: in-house vs outsourced payroll and how to choose a payroll provider.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest way to run payroll in the UK?+
For very small teams, software you run yourself has the lowest fee but the highest risk and time cost. Outsourcing at £5 per payslip is usually the cheapest option once your time and compliance risk are counted.
Is outsourced payroll better than payroll software?+
Outsourcing moves the work and the risk to qualified accountants. Software is fine if you have the time and expertise to run it, check it and keep up with rule changes.
When should I hire an in-house payroll person?+
Usually once you have a large or complex workforce, multiple pay frequencies and enough volume to keep a specialist busy.
Your first payslip is £5. Start in minutes.
No set-up fee, no lock-in. Tell us about your team and a qualified payroll accountant will come back the same working day.