On this page
- What to look for in a payroll provider
- Twelve questions to ask
- Pricing and what it hides
- Regulation, qualifications and insurance
- Service levels and communication
- Data security and your data
- Contracts, exit terms and red flags
- Bureau, software or accountant?
- Questions about growth and flexibility
- Checking references and reviews
- Making the decision
Key takeaways
- Payroll is a legal duty with real consequences, so the provider you choose matters more than most suppliers.
- Put these to every provider on your shortlist, and note the answers in writing.
- Compare the total annual cost, not the monthly headline.
- Payroll is not itself a regulated activity, so anyone can offer it, which is why professional status is a useful signal.
- Good service is about reliability and access.
Questions about this? WhatsApp a payroll accountant or call 0800 644 1258.
What to look for in a payroll provider
Payroll is a legal duty with real consequences, so the provider you choose matters more than most suppliers. The best ones combine technical competence, professional accountability, clear pricing, reliable service and good communication. The cheapest option is rarely the best, and the most expensive is not necessarily the safest, so compare on a clear set of criteria.
Start by deciding what you need: the number of employees, the pay frequency, the complexity of your pay, whether you need pensions and statutory pay, and whether you want accounts and tax support as well. The more precisely you describe your needs, the easier it is to compare quotes properly.
Twelve questions to ask
Put these to every provider on your shortlist, and note the answers in writing.
- Who is regulated, and what qualifications does the team hold?
- What does the headline price include, and what is extra?
- Are there set-up fees, minimum charges or minimum terms?
- How do you handle pension auto-enrolment and the year-end forms?
- What happens if something goes wrong, and who pays for errors?
- Who will I speak to, and how quickly do you respond?
- How is my data secured and where is it stored?
- What is your cut-off before payday, and how do changes reach you?
- How do I leave, and how do I get my data back?
- Do you offer accounts and tax support too?
- Can I see independent reviews and references?
- Can I see a sample payslip and payroll report?
Pricing and what it hides
Compare the total annual cost, not the monthly headline. Add up set-up fees, per-run charges, per-employee charges, pension submissions, starters and leavers, year-end forms and any minimum fee. A low per-payslip price with a high minimum monthly fee can cost more than a flat price. Ask for a written quote based on your actual payroll, with the pay frequency you use.
Our price is £5 per payslip per month, with no set-up fee, no contract and nothing extra for pensions, RTI, P45s, P60s or statutory pay calculations. Use that kind of simplicity as a benchmark for the other quotes you receive.
Regulation, qualifications and insurance
Payroll is not itself a regulated activity, so anyone can offer it, which is why professional status is a useful signal. An accountancy firm regulated by a body such as the ICAEW or ACCA works to professional standards, must carry professional indemnity insurance and is accountable if things go wrong. Check the firm's registration in the professional directory.
Ask about the qualifications of the people who will actually run your payroll. AAT, ACCA, ICAEW and CIPP qualifications all indicate training, and a team that holds them is more likely to keep up with the changes that affect you.
Service levels and communication
Good service is about reliability and access. Ask how and when you submit changes, how quickly payslips are returned for approval, who answers your questions, and what happens when the usual contact is away. A named contact who knows your business is far better than a ticket queue.
Test it before you sign. Send a realistic question and see how long a response takes and whether it is accurate. The response you get during the sales process is usually the best you will ever see, so a poor one is a warning.
Data security and your data
Your provider will hold sensitive personal and financial data, so look for a written data processing agreement, encryption in transit and at rest, access controls, multi-factor authentication and regular backups. Ask where data is stored and whether it leaves the UK. A provider registered with the Information Commissioner's Office takes its obligations seriously.
Check what happens to the data when you leave: you should be able to get a complete export of your payroll records, and the provider should delete their copies when required.
Contracts, exit terms and red flags
Read the contract carefully. Check the minimum term, the notice period, automatic renewal, price increase clauses and the cost of leaving. The best providers keep clients by doing a good job, not by locking them in. Red flags include vague pricing, no named contact, no professional regulation, long lock-in contracts, refusal to show a sample payslip and pressure to sign quickly.
Other warning signs are a provider who cannot explain how they handle auto-enrolment, who does not mention the minimum wage, or who treats mistakes as the client's problem.
Bureau, software or accountant?
There are three broad routes. Payroll software gives you control at a low monthly cost, but you do the work and carry the responsibility. A specialist payroll bureau does the work for you, usually at a per-payslip price. An accountancy firm can do the same and add accounts, tax and advice under one roof, which is helpful for company directors and growing businesses. Think about whether you want to run payroll, or simply have it done correctly.
Questions about growth and flexibility
Choose a provider who can grow with you. Ask whether adding employees changes the price per payslip, whether they can handle weekly, fortnightly and four-weekly pay, and whether they cope with pensions, statutory pay, benefits and multiple companies. A provider that handles only simple monthly payrolls will become a limitation the moment your business changes. Also check what happens during holidays and busy periods, because deadlines do not move.
Checking references and reviews
Independent reviews tell you how a provider behaves when something goes wrong. Look for comments about response times, accuracy and how mistakes were handled, not only star ratings. Ask for a reference from a client with a similar size and type of business to yours, and ask that client what they would change.
Making the decision
Score each shortlisted provider on price, regulation, qualifications, service, security and contract terms, and weight them to match your priorities. Speak to a reference or read independent reviews, and run a short trial if you can. Then decide, and plan the switch carefully using the steps in our guide to switching provider.
If you want to see how we compare, ask us for a written quote, a sample payslip and our terms. We will answer all twelve questions above in writing.
Monthly payroll
Your price
How many employees?
10 × £5 per month
£50
- Set-up fee
- £0
- Contract
- None
Includes PAYE, RTI, pensions, P60s and P45s. Prices exclude VAT where applicable.
Questions answered
Is a bureau better than software?+
A bureau transfers the workload and risk to a professional. Software gives you control but you carry the responsibility.
Should my payroll provider be regulated?+
It is not required, but a regulated accountancy firm works to professional standards and carries insurance.
What is a reasonable price for payroll?+
Prices vary widely. Compare the total annual cost, including every extra. Ours is £5 per payslip per month.
Can I try a provider before committing?+
Ask about a trial period or run a parallel payroll for one pay period before switching fully.
What should I do if my provider makes a mistake?+
Report it immediately, ask them to correct it and confirm who bears any penalty. This should be set out in your agreement.
Written and reviewed by the Accotax payroll team
Accotax is an ICAEW regulated accountancy firm in Morden, London, with ACCA and AAT qualified staff, rated 4.9 on Google from 300+ reviews. About us · Verify on the ICAEW directory
Sources and further reading
General information for UK employers, not personal advice. Rates and rules change, so check GOV.UK or ask us before you act. Canonical page: https://payrollservices.accountants/guides/choosing-a-payroll-provider