On this page
- Why employers switch
- Is mid-year switching allowed?
- What you need to gather
- Authorising your new provider with HMRC
- Carrying across year-to-date figures
- Pensions during the switch
- Running the first pay period
- A sample switching timeline
- Telling your employees
- What it costs to switch
- Checking the switch has worked
- Common mistakes when switching
Key takeaways
- Employers move payroll for several reasons.
- Yes.
- A new provider needs a defined set of information to take over.
- Your new provider needs to be authorised to act for you on PAYE.
- This is the step that matters most.
Questions about this? WhatsApp a payroll accountant or call 0800 644 1258.
Why employers switch
Employers move payroll for several reasons. The price has crept up, or hidden extras have appeared on the invoice. The service has slipped, with slow responses or repeated errors. The in-house person is leaving and nobody wants to take over. The business has outgrown its software, or it wants payroll, accounts and tax handled by one firm. Whatever the reason, the process is simpler than most employers fear.
A well-planned switch should be invisible to employees. Their pay, tax, National Insurance and pension should be unchanged, and the only difference they notice is a new payslip layout.
Is mid-year switching allowed?
Yes. You can change provider at any point in the tax year. April is convenient because there are no year-to-date figures to transfer, but it is also the busiest time for providers, and waiting means more months of paying for a service you are unhappy with. A mid-year move needs the year-to-date figures to be carried across accurately, which is routine for an experienced provider.
The best moment to switch is the start of a pay period, so that one provider handles the whole period. Moving at the start of a tax month is the tidiest, but it is not essential.
What you need to gather
A new provider needs a defined set of information to take over. Collecting it before you start avoids delays.
- Your PAYE reference and Accounts Office reference
- Year-to-date figures for each employee: gross pay, tax, National Insurance, student loans, pension and statutory pay
- A list of employees with their National Insurance numbers, tax codes, pay rates and start dates
- Details of your pension scheme, including provider, scheme reference and contribution rules
- Your most recent payslips and payroll reports from the previous provider
- Details of any benefits, salary sacrifice arrangements, attachment of earnings orders and holiday balances
Carrying across year-to-date figures
This is the step that matters most. The new provider must enter each employee's cumulative pay, tax and National Insurance so far this year, so that the next payslip calculates tax correctly on a cumulative basis. If these figures are wrong, every later payslip will be wrong too.
A careful provider reconciles the opening figures to HMRC's records and to the final payslips from the old system, and runs a check payroll before going live. If the old provider is slow to hand over data, the figures can usually be rebuilt from the last payslips, P45 information and HMRC's records.
Pensions during the switch
Pension arrangements need extra care. The scheme itself usually stays with the same provider, but the payroll system sending contributions changes, and the new provider must be set up with the scheme reference, the contribution rules and any staging dates. Check that the earnings basis, tax relief method and contribution percentages are copied correctly, and that the first contribution schedule agrees with what the scheme expects.
Auto-enrolment assessments must continue without a gap. Make sure the new provider has each employee's enrolment status, opt-out dates and the next re-enrolment date, so that nothing is missed during the transition.
Running the first pay period
For the first pay period, ask the new provider to prepare the payroll and show you the figures next to the previous month's, so that you can spot differences. Confirm each employee's net pay matches what you expect, then approve and release. After the run, check that the submission to HMRC has been filed and that the amount due agrees to the payroll summary.
Keep the old provider's records safe and make sure they file the final submission for their last period, so that there are no gaps or overlaps.
A sample switching timeline
A typical switch runs over four to six weeks. In week one you choose the provider and agree terms. In week two you give notice to the old provider, gather the information above and authorise the new one. In week three the new provider builds the payroll and loads the opening figures. In week four they run a check payroll alongside the old one and you compare results. The first live run follows at the next payday, and the old provider files their final submission for the period before it.
Telling your employees
Let staff know a week or two ahead that payslips will come from a new provider and may look different. Explain that their pay date, tax code and pension are not changing, and tell them where to send questions. A short note prevents a flood of worried queries on the first payday, and it gives employees a chance to flag any details that look wrong.
If payslips are now delivered online, include simple instructions for logging in, and offer paper copies to anyone who needs them.
What it costs to switch
Switching should not cost you much. Check your current contract for notice periods and any exit fee, and ask the new provider whether they charge to set up. We do not charge a set-up fee, and we take on the opening balances, pension details and first parallel run as part of the normal service. Overlapping for one pay period is the only real extra cost, and it is a sensible price for certainty that the first live run is right.
Checking the switch has worked
After the first two pay runs, reconcile the payroll to HMRC's online account, check pension contributions agree to the scheme, and confirm year-to-date figures on each payslip match your expectations. Catching an error in month two is far easier than discovering it at year end.
Common mistakes when switching
The recurring errors are transferring the wrong year-to-date figures, filing with both providers in the same period, losing pension scheme details, changing the pay date by accident, and failing to tell employees. Another is not reading the old contract, so the notice period or termination fees come as a surprise.
Read your existing contract before you give notice, and plan the timing so that you are not paying for two services longer than necessary. Our payroll set-up and switching service handles the entire process for you, with no set-up fee.
Monthly payroll
Your price
How many employees?
10 × £5 per month
£50
- Set-up fee
- £0
- Contract
- None
Includes PAYE, RTI, pensions, P60s and P45s. Prices exclude VAT where applicable.
Questions answered
How long does a switch take?+
Usually one pay period. Larger or messier payrolls may take longer.
Do I need to tell HMRC?+
You authorise the new provider as your agent through HMRC. Your PAYE scheme stays the same.
Will my employees notice?+
They will see a new payslip layout. Their tax, National Insurance and pension should be unchanged.
What if my old provider is slow to hand over?+
We can build opening balances from payslips, P45 information and HMRC records.
Do you charge a set-up fee to take over payroll?+
No. There is no set-up fee, and you pay only £5 per payslip per month.
Written and reviewed by the Accotax payroll team
Accotax is an ICAEW regulated accountancy firm in Morden, London, with ACCA and AAT qualified staff, rated 4.9 on Google from 300+ reviews. About us · Verify on the ICAEW directory
Sources and further reading
General information for UK employers, not personal advice. Rates and rules change, so check GOV.UK or ask us before you act. Canonical page: https://payrollservices.accountants/guides/how-to-switch-payroll-provider