On this page
Key takeaways
- Payroll mistakes are rarely dramatic.
- These items must be in place before the first payday.
- Do these every time you pay anyone.
- Reconcile the payroll to the accounts and to HMRC's online account.
- Review statutory pay claims and recoveries, check that the Employment Allowance is claimed if you are eligible, and look at the minimum wage position of anyone on low pay or apprentice rates.
Questions about this? WhatsApp a payroll accountant or call 0800 644 1258.
Why a payroll checklist helps
Payroll mistakes are rarely dramatic. They are small, repeated and unnoticed: a wrong tax code carried forward, a missed pension assessment, an overtime rate left out of holiday pay. Each one is cheap to fix when caught early and expensive when found by HMRC or a former employee years later. A checklist turns a vague worry into a routine, and it is the cheapest compliance tool there is.
The list below covers the 20 things every UK employer should get right. It is organised by when you do them: before you hire, every pay run, and every month, quarter and year. You can also use our interactive checklists to tick items off and print them.
Before you hire
These items must be in place before the first payday. They are easy to do at the start and painful to do retrospectively.
- Register as an employer with HMRC and receive your PAYE and Accounts Office references
- Check that employers' liability insurance is in force, usually with at least £5 million cover
- Verify and copy the right to work documents before the person starts
- Issue a written statement of employment particulars by the first day
- Choose a workplace pension scheme and know your auto-enrolment dates
Every pay run
Do these every time you pay anyone. Most payroll errors come from skipping one of them when you are busy.
- Gross pay matches contract, hours and any variable pay, bonuses or deductions
- Pay is at or above the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage for the employee's age, after deductions
- Holiday is accrued or paid correctly, including regular overtime for the relevant staff
- Each employee's tax code is current and starters have the right code
- Employee and employer National Insurance are calculated with the correct category letter
- Pension eligibility is assessed and contributions are deducted on the right earnings
- Payslips are issued on or before payday with the required detail
- The Full Payment Submission is filed to HMRC on or before payday
Every month
Reconcile the payroll to the accounts and to HMRC's online account. Check that the amount due to HMRC matches your liability, and pay it by the 22nd if you pay electronically. Pay pension contributions to your provider by the 22nd of the following month and make sure the contribution schedule is complete. Review starters and leavers: each leaver should have a P45 and a correct final pay including accrued holiday, and each starter should have all documents on file.
A monthly check also catches changes you have not told payroll about, such as pay rises, new overtime patterns or employees whose hours changed enough to alter their pension eligibility.
Every quarter and every year
Review statutory pay claims and recoveries, check that the Employment Allowance is claimed if you are eligible, and look at the minimum wage position of anyone on low pay or apprentice rates. Each April, update rates, thresholds and the minimum wage on the date they change, and review the tax codes HMRC sends.
At year end, file the final submission by 19 April, issue P60s by 31 May, report benefits on P11D forms by 6 July and pay Class 1A National Insurance by 22 July. Every three years, carry out auto-enrolment re-enrolment and redeclare compliance. Our year-end checklist goes into this in detail.
Records you must keep
Keep payroll records for at least three years from the end of the tax year, including payslips, pay, hours worked, deductions, National Insurance and tax. Keep pension records for six years, statutory pay records for three years and right-to-work evidence for the duration of employment plus two years. Store them securely under data protection rules, restrict access and delete them when no longer needed.
Good records are also your best defence in a dispute, because they show what was agreed and what was paid.
How to use this checklist in practice
A checklist only works if it is used the same way every time. Pick a fixed day each month for the review, such as the working day after payday, and give one named person responsibility for it. Print or save the list and tick it off, rather than relying on memory. Keep each month's completed checklist with your payroll records, because it is evidence that you take compliance seriously if HMRC ever asks.
If you use a payroll provider, send them the list and ask them to confirm each item in writing. The conversation tells you quickly whether they are doing the work properly or whether you have been relying on assumptions.
Red flags that your payroll needs attention
Some warning signs suggest a problem even before you complete the list. Employees regularly ask why their tax code has changed or why their pay is different from the last month. HMRC notices or letters about underpaid tax arrive more than once a year. You cannot explain how a particular payslip figure was calculated. Pension contributions are paid late or by a different amount from the schedule. Holiday balances have not been updated for months. Anyone has been paid in cash outside the payroll.
Any one of these is worth investigating immediately. Several together means your payroll needs a proper review, either by a qualified provider or by an accountant who can reconcile it to HMRC's records.
Who should approve each pay run
Good control means the person who prepares the payroll is not the only person who approves it. Even in a small business, the owner or a second person should check the totals against the previous month, look at any large changes, and approve before payments are released. This one habit catches duplicated employees, wrong rates, missing starters and keying errors.
Record who approved each run and when. With an outsourced service, that approval is part of the process: you review the summary we prepare, confirm it and only then are payslips issued and HMRC notified.
When to ask for help
If you find you cannot tick several of these boxes, or you are not sure what some of them mean, get help sooner rather than later. A payroll provider or accountant can review your set-up, correct errors and take the process off your hands. Our service handles every item above as part of the £5 per payslip price, and our free checklists help you check your own position first.
Monthly payroll
Your price
How many employees?
10 × £5 per month
£50
- Set-up fee
- £0
- Contract
- None
Includes PAYE, RTI, pensions, P60s and P45s. Prices exclude VAT where applicable.
Questions answered
What records must I keep?+
Pay records, hours, deductions, pension information, statutory pay records and right-to-work documents, for the periods set out above.
How often should I review payroll?+
Every pay run, with a deeper review each month and at year end.
What is the most common payroll error?+
Wrong tax codes and missed pension assessments are the commonest, followed by minimum wage underpayments.
Do I need a checklist if I use a provider?+
Yes, to check they are doing it. Ask them to confirm each item, especially pensions and year end.
Where can I find an interactive checklist?+
Our checklists section has tick-off lists you can save and print.
Written and reviewed by the Accotax payroll team
Accotax is an ICAEW regulated accountancy firm in Morden, London, with ACCA and AAT qualified staff, rated 4.9 on Google from 300+ reviews. About us · Verify on the ICAEW directory
Sources and further reading
- GOV.UK: National Minimum Wage and Living Wage rates
- GOV.UK: PAYE for employers
- GOV.UK: Running payroll
General information for UK employers, not personal advice. Rates and rules change, so check GOV.UK or ask us before you act. Canonical page: https://payrollservices.accountants/guides/payroll-checklist-for-employers